Posted on July 14, 2018 in Washington Watch
By Dr. James J. Zogby
On Wednesday morning, I watched an amazing debate unfolding in the Irish Seanad (Senate), as members spoke for and against a bill to prohibit the importation of Israeli goods produced in settlements in occupied Palestinian lands. The legislation in question is the Control of Economic Activity (Occupied Territory) Bill 2018, which would "make it an offense for a person to import or sell goods or services originating in occupied territory or to extract resources from an occupied territory". The bill had been introduced by independent Senator Frances Black and a group of co-sponsors earlier in the...Read more
Posted by Guest on June 28, 2018 in Blog
By Allison Ulven
On Thursday, June 28, the Foundation for Middle East Peace hosted a panel discussion titled “Complex Palestinian Narratives & Competing Political Visions.” The event addressed the problems and misconceptions Americans have about what the people of Palestine are seeking. Many tend to have a “single, monolithic viewpoint,” neglecting the full spectrum of views on the situation. The panel discussed different narratives and perspectives from the time of the Nakba in 1948 to the present.
The panelists included our Deputy Director Omar Baddar, ANERA’s Rula Bawardi, the Museum of Palestinian People’s Nizar Farsakh, with moderation by Al-Arabiya’s Muna Shikaki.
Shikaki began the discussion by giving a brief overview of the history of the Palestinian situation dating back to the 1930s, alluding to the crystallization of Palestinian identity into a nationalist movement during the period of British colonial rule. Following the establishment of the state of Israel, Palestinians turned to neighboring Arab governments for support. The late ‘50s brought about the Fatah nationalist movement, and the ‘60s gave rise to the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO), which later came to lead advocacy on behalf of Palestinians.
There are varying visions for how to achieve Palestinians’ goals and how to resolve the Israeli-Palestinian impasse, but much of the debate recently has centered around the one-state solution vs the two-state solution. You can see the varying levels of support these proposals have among Palestinians and others on this recent poll by Zogby Research Services.
But with the failure of all solution visions to materialize thus far, the question is: Where do Palestinians go from here?
Nizar Farsakh spoke first about the different perspectives of Palestinians in the West Bank, Gaza Strip and in refugee camps, and how we make sense of the events that took place. Nizar was born and raised in Dubai, but also spend time living in the occupied Palestinian territories and in the United States. His father was from a town in the West Bank where they still had family living, and they would send money and support them. When he moved there in 1999, he said he was surprised that his family in Palestinian referred to “Israel,” instead of his then-preferred terminology while living in the diaspora, referring to the “1948 areas.” He also remembered when Palestinians declared statehood in Algiers in 1988 how some celebrated it as an accomplishment while others mourned it as a step that came at the expense of Nakba refugees. Another aspect to the narrative was the divide between the West Bank and Gaza and how neither leadership was certain that they wanted to help each other.
Rula Bawardi spoke next about the specific experiences of Palestinians in Jerusalem. Rula’s father was forced to leave a particular area in Jerusalem in 1948, but came to establish residency in East Jerusalem. Although they were refugees, they did not live in refugee camps. Her father was able to build a successful clothing design business, receive an education, and provide a good life for the family. Her father participated in boycotts with his business long before the BDS movement became a thing. When the peace process eventually began, Rula remembered Palestinian children handing over olive branches to Israeli soldiers, in what she recalls as a naive hope that Israel was about to end the occupation. However, Israel built more settlements, and Jewish settlers began occupying Palestinian homes. Israel would refuse Palestinians building permits inside the occupied territories, and would often demolish their homes, and revoke their residencies. Closures on the West Bank turned the vibrant Jerusalem into a “goth ghost town.” The physical separation between different parts of the occupied territories had also fragmented Palestinian identity. The main struggle facing Jerusalemites is how to remain there and keep their ID’s despite the oppressions and economic strangulation they face by Israel.
Finally, Omar Baddar spoke about the experiences of Palestinians in the diaspora and in the United States. Omar argued that the Palestinian people are diverse in their perspectives. He said the main political parties in Palestine, Fatah and Hamas, were losing public support because neither succeeded in producing a clear strategy for Palestinians to get behind. In the United States, most Palestinians don’t have a loyalty to either political group, Omar said. What divides Palestinians in the US are the different agendas and strategies to advocate and move forward with a solution. In terms of the debate over the one-state and two-state solutions, a huge part of the divide related to different assessments on which was more “pragmatic” and “realistic” to pursue. Right now, Omar argued that there is no clear political road map that can lead to either solution, which is why there has been a shift in advocacy that focuses on human rights, primarily seeking to end U.S. support for Israel’s violations of Palestinian rights. And that effort is beginning to show signs of hope, as with the introduction of a bill by Betty McCollum to end any U.S. financial support for Israel’s detention of Palestinian children. Omar argued that diversity of views is a strength in the movement for Palestinian rights, so long as people acknowledge the basics: That Israel is oppressing the Palestinians, and that we need to bring about pressure to change Israel’s policies.
All of the panelists provided clear viewpoints to the many different narratives of the Palestinian people. It is important that we consider all of these perspectives and understand the complexities of the issues as we work for a solution. You can watch the full panel below.
Allison Ulven is a 2018 summer intern at the Arab American Institute.
Posted by Guest on June 25, 2018 in Blog
By Blaise Malley
For the first time in the chamber’s history, the House of Representatives introduced a bill that addressed Israel’s abuse of Palestinian human rights. The bill was introduced on November 14, 2017 by Betty McCollum (D--MN), and is currently being heard in the House Foreign Affairs Committee. Over the course of the next few months 28 other representatives, all Democrats, co-sponsored McCollum’s bill. On June 25, 2018, the Defense for Children Palestine and the American Friends Service Committee (AFSC) hosted a briefing on the bill.
While the very facts that there is a bill being discussed...Read more
Posted on June 22, 2018 in Countdown Vol. 18 No. 3: The Nightmare Never Ends
Before she was chased by protesters from a Mexican restaurant in DC over family separation at the border, DHS Secretary Nielsen made a trip to Israel, which received scant attention in the national media despite posing significant domestic and foreign policy implications. The DHS Office of Public Affairs (OPA) issued multiple press releases during the fun-filled ‘let’s adopt discriminatory policies’ tour. The first press release (Jun. 8) discusses Secretary Nielsen’s itinerary, beginning with the inaugural International Homeland Security Forum in “Jerusalem, Israel.” Unlike prior U.S....
Posted by Guest on June 14, 2018 in Blog
By Blaise Malley This month, in two countries halfway around the world from one another, sports took the center stage in important political disputes, with athletes taking a stand for justice in two very different arenas. Israeli Soccer Team pays the Price for Government’s Actions After weeks of unarmed protests in the Gaza Strip were met by Israel’s use of lethal force and resulted in more than 13,000 casualties, the international community started to take notice. On 5 June, the...Read more
Posted on June 08, 2018 in Countdown
DREAMers Countdown: It’s been 275 days since President Trump moved to end DACA. The courts did step in to block the move, but Congress has yet to provide a permanent fix.Read more
Posted by Guest on May 30, 2018 in Blog
By Blaise Malley
Donald Trump’s election as President of the United States presented Democrats with an ideal counterpoint to some of their long-held beliefs. Many in Congress have seized the opportunity to combat Trump’s divisive and regressive policies. However, one area in which they have continued to fall short is regarding the conflict in Israel and Palestine.
Criticizing Israel has historically been a difficult road for politicians to travel, but with President Trump’s essentially unconditional support for the country, and Democratic voters’ increasing sympathy toward Palestine, it appeared possible that the position of the party toward the decades-long...Read more
Posted by Mona Ahmed on May 29, 2018 in Blog
To mark the 70th anniversary of the Nakba, The Jerusalem Fund & Palestine Center hosted Arab American Institute President, Dr. James Zogby for a talk entitled, “Political Zionism and the Root of Dispossession” on Tuesday, May 22nd. In his talk, Dr. Zogby cited his newly republished book, Palestinians: The Invisible Victims to address how the ideology and practice of political Zionism continues to silence Palestinians and forces them into the role of invisible victims.
Dr. Zogby highlighted...Read more
Posted on May 23, 2018 in Action Alerts
A bicameral bill was introduced in the House and Senate that seeks to restrict criticism of Israel at the expense of our First Amendment protected right to free speech. Introduced in the House as H.R.5924 by Representatives Peter J. Roskam (R-IL), Ted Deutch (D-FL), Doug Collins (R-GA), and Jerrold Nadler (D-NY), and in the Senate as S.2940 by Senators Tim Scott (R-SC) and Bob Casey (D-PA), the legislation includes an overly broad, political definition of anti-Semitism, which includes criticism of the state of Israel.
Entitled the Anti-Semitism Awareness Act of 2018, the bill does not actually...Read more